Start of game
14th
French army have orders to attack San Pedro
The
town is held by 2nd Spanish army
The
Spanish are deployed either side of San Pedro at the top of the table
Spanish
CinC has taken command of the only cavalry brigade in the army
The
French are deployed at the bottom of the table
French
CinC has taken command of cavalry brigades of 41st and 42nd
corps
41st
Baden corps is on the right bank of the river Guadiana
The
river can only be forded by one of the three bridges
French
Army – 10 infantry brigades, 3 cavalry brigade, 3 corps artillery
Spanish Army – 11 infantry brigades, 1 cavalry brigade, 3 corps artillery
Battle of San Pedro –
Move 6
By
midday the Spanish CinC ordered a general retreat
42nd
Polish corps routed the Spanish artillery and two infantry brigades
40th
French corps artillery were within close range of the town
41st
Baden corps had fought their way across the northern bridge and routed two
infantry brigades
Only
the French cavalry had failed in their mission
The
Baden cavalry fought four rounds of melee and three were a draw
They
won the fourth round but by then had lost 30% casualties
The
Polish lancers charged the Spanish artillery twice, and were repulsed twice
with 20% casualties
The
French lost 5 cavalry casualties (500 men)
The Spanish lost 8 infantry, 4 artillery and 4 cavalry casualties (3900 men)
Comments
The
French started this battle concentrated and deployed
So
it was always very likely that they would win
But
it was not anticipated that they would win so quickly
After
just six moves the Spanish abandoned the town and retreated
At
midday all three Spanish corps were still in position and they held the town
However
4th and 5th corps had suffered heavy casualties
6th
corps still held San Pedro. But French
artillery were within close range of the town
French
infantry were moving into position to assault the town as soon as the garrison
was shaken
41st
Baden corps had the most difficult task
They
were deployed on the eastern side of the river, which could only be crossed by
one of the bridges
A
defended river crossing was always going to be difficult.
The
French CinC took command of the Baden and Polish cavalry brigades
He
would advance along the west side of the river and attack in support of the
Baden infantry
He
would force the Spanish infantry into square and distract or capture their
artillery
The
Baden cavalry led the advance, and they were charged by the Spanish militia
lancers
The
Spanish held their own for three moves, and both sides suffered 30% casualties
The
Baden horse won the fourth round of melee and routed the Spanish
But
in doing so suffered so many casualties that they were non operational
The
Polish lancers were given the task of attacking the Spanish artillery
They
suffered 10% casualties in their first attack and withdrew shaken
Having
rallied they again attacked the guns, and again were held at bay and shaken
with another 10%
However
they forced the Spanish gunners to concentrate on the left bank of the river
In
doing so the Baden infantry were allowed to reach the bridge without any
casualties
And
the Baden artillery were allowed to deploy within short range of the Spanish
infantry holding the bridge
This
is the first game in which infantry have been able to cross a defended river
It
would not have been possible without the support of the two cavalry brigades
Cavalry
were the only casualties suffered by the French
They
lost 5 casualties between the two brigades
This loss will have a significant effect on future battles.
Tradgardmastare,
ReplyDeleteAfter reading this battle report, I am left with the impression that the Spanish are very much on the back foot, and I cannot see them winning this campaign … unless the French make some serious blunders.
Perhaps some guerrilla activity might slow the French, but I cannot see them losing.
All the best,
Bob
Hi Bob,
DeleteThanks for your comment
I would expect the French to do well during the early part of the campaign. They are concentrated, have not detached as many brigades as they will need to later on, and they have not yet taken any casualties.
Despite that I am a little disappointed how poorly the Spanish are doing. I have made a few adjustments to their order of battle to improve their performance on the table. There are more B class, and less C class, infantry brigades than previously. I have also given them more 12 pdr guns than the French. This was intended to counter the higher number of French cavalry. However when firing the Spanish gunners have consistently rolled low dice, and this has completely destroyed that particular advantage.
It is still a little early to determine whether I have the balance right or not. As the French advance they will have to leave more infantry brigades behind to secure their lines of communications. As they receive battle casualties their brigades will become more brittle and less likely to pass morale tests.
But, as always, it will depend on the dice roll. And it is often difficult to remember how well, or bad, they have been. There is a strong tendency to remember that particularly bad, or really good, dice roll. The actual average over a number of games is more difficult to determine.
If things continue to go badly for the Spanish I will have to find other ways to shift the balance between them and the French.
best regards
Paul
Paul
ReplyDeleteIt's certainly looking bad for the Spanish on the battlefield, but looking at the earlier campaign map, the French logistic position looks pretty parlous what with all those Spanish guerilla bands running around loose.
If this campaign is part of the wider war you're running (it usually is!) I'd suggest staying with the present game mechanics until the end of the campaign before determining whether there really is a problem with them. It may be that French 'wastage' will be the greater owing to having to protect their LOCs more effectively.
I do like the look of these battles, especially this latest one!
Cheers,
Ion
Hi Ion
DeleteThanks for your comment
As you know the whole campaign covers five different area, three in Germany and two in Spain. And by far the most difficult to get the right "feel" is southern Spain, where the French fight the Spanish.
My aim is that the French should (normally) win set battles, but should struggle with keeping their armies concentrated and in particular their lines of supply.
All of the campaign phases aim for about six battles, so it is important that the French win the first three. As they advance to the next three, which would include the city which is the phase objective, they should suffer attrition from guerrilla attacks on their lines of supply and also having to detach brigades to guard their lines of supply.
The problem is that wargaming does not always allow fine tuning. Given that most rules, and mine in particular, rely on the roll of a dice this is not surprising.
I will, of course, wait until the end of the campaign phase before assessing whether the rules need to be changed. But I have found in the past that changing rules to correct one aspect can often produce another completely unexpected one.
I try not to have favourites between the different campaign armies. But I must admit I do like the complex supply problems in southern Spain.
regards
Paul