Battle of Montoro – table at start of game
Start of move 1
Both armies start the game on the table.
At the top the Spanish are deployed in and around Montoro
1, 2 and 3 corps are in front of the town, 4 corps at the rear
The three French corps are deployed with one corps in each square
There are three game objectives
Farm on the left, small woods in the centre and large woods on the right
The side which has possession of at least two objectives a t the end of 12 moves will win
End of move 12
On the right 39th Vistula corps have taken the farm, 3rd Spanish corps is in rout
The Polish advance was delayed by having to move through the large woods
They then pinned the Spanish to the left of the farm, and attacked the farm itself
This was achieved without much help from their lancer brigade, who failed their morale and routed
2nd Spanish orps did not have any cavalry, so this was not the disaster it might have been
After a short fight all four Spanish brigades routed (see yellow stars) and abandoned the farm
In the centre 38th French corps had a more difficult task. 2nd Spanish corps was supported by artillery from the reserve, and also cavalry from 1st corps. No attempt was made to engage this strong force, so the attack on the small woods at the T junction had to a frontal one. The French did eventually take the woods, but were unable to hold it against an attack by two brigades from the reserve 4th corps.
37th young guard corps attacked the large woods on the right. 1st Spanish corps held the two northern wood sections, and were positioned to counter attack any French who entered the two southern sections. This meant that the French artillery were unable to engage the Spanish infantry. They therefore exchanged fire with the Spanish artillery, but lost the engagement and routed with 10% casualties. The battle for the woods was therefore an infantry affair. Not surprising the French young guard took the woods and 1st Spanish corps retreated. But the French has no reserve to counter a counter attack by two brigades from 4th Spanish corps.
The French lost 13 infantry and 1 artillery casualties (5300 men)
The Spanish lost 21 infantry and 1 artillery casualties (8500 men)
The French had four brigades in rout, the Spanish had six
The Spanish held two of the three objectives at the end of 12 moves and won the battle
Comments
This was the first battle of the Cordova campaign, it was also the first time that the Spanish outnumbered the French in infantry and artillery.
The French had 12 infantry brigades, 3 cavalry brigades and 3 corps artillery
The Spanish had 16 infantry brigades, 2 cavalry brigades and 4 cavalry.
The Spanish deployed half of their artillery, and all of their cavalry, in the centre. The French dare not attack such a powerful force, and directed their main attack at the two flanks. They created a reserve of two cavalry brigades, one artillery and one infantry brigade to pin the Spanish centre.
The attack on the left went well, but losing their artillery on the right flank was a serious blow to the French. The loss of a lancer brigade on the left flank was not so serious because the Spanish did not have sufficient cavalry to take advantage of their loss.
The main difference was the much more powerful Spanish infantry. The French took all three objectives, but were then too weak to withstand the counter attack by four brigades from the Spanish reserve.
This game was the first test of the stronger Spanish army, and too soon to come to any conclusions.


Wow! This reads like a humdinger of a battle. Ealy days, but it seems to me the sort of result that one got from the rare 'Spanish-only' victories of the Peninsular War: early French successes until they run out of steam with the Spanish battered and bruised but still standing.
ReplyDeleteInteresting!
Cheers,
Ion
Hi Ion
DeleteThe French performed much better than I expected, given they were weaker in infantry and artillery. Despite this they inflicted much heavier casualties on the Spanish. They have to be very careful to avoid casualties to their elite infantry and cavalry, because they are what makes the difference when attacking. It will be interesting to see how that works in the second set of battles, when both sides start with existing casualties
regards
Paul
Thistlebarrow,
ReplyDeleteA very interesting battle. The fact that the French were outnumbered yet still took the three objectives says much for their potential, but in the face of such an overwhelming Spanish army it’s not surprising that they were unable to hold all of them.
This seems to have all the makings of being a great campaign.
All the best,
Bob
Hi Bob
DeleteThe larger Spanish army is causing some technical problems.
First not enough space on the table to deploy them all
Second difficult to make best use of the reserve Spanish corps, they always seem to be in the wrong place.
Third not sufficient time for the French to recover from a counter attack
The normal three corps per side is the result of many years of use
I will have to think outside the box to see if I can make this new order of battle work
All will depend on the second set of three battles, when both sides start with casualties
regards
Paul