Sunday, 15 February 2026

Cordova Campaign – Day Two

 

10 September 1813 – Southern Spain – Day 2

French attack Espinal
13 French Army occupy Montoro
14 French Army observe El Carpio
15 French Army attack Espinal

Spanish win battle of Montoro
1 Spanish Army retreat to Muriano
2 Spanish Army hold El Carpio
3 Spanish Army hold Espinal

Battle of Montoro – end of move 12

Comments

Although the Spanish won the battle of Montoro, they had suffered so many casualties that they had to retreat the following day. They suffered 21 infantry casualties (8500) against 15 French (5300). They also had six brigades in rout, against four French. 2nd Spanish corps had suffered particularly with all four infantry brigades in rout.

They won the battle because they held two of the three objectives at the end of 12 moves.

Most of the Spanish casualties were concentrated in 1st and 2nd corps, who bore the brunt of the fighting for the woods in the centre and the woods on the right. 3rd corps abandoned the farm on the left without any serious fighting. 4th corps were the Spanish reserve and only committed at the end of the battle to retake the woods on the right. They suffered light casualties because 37th French corps were shaken by the earlier fighting and had no casualties.

The lighter French casualties are spread more evenly between their three corps. This will make it easier to rally and regroup to fight a second day at Montoro if the Spanish did not retreat.

The second French attack is in the south, where marshal Augereau is ordered to attack Espinar. The French strategic plan is to force First Spanish army in the north, and Third Spanish army in the south to retreat. They will then attack Second Spanish army at El Carpio on the east bank of the river Guadalquivir and destroy them before they can retreat to the west bank.

For this plan to work they will have to defeat Third Spanish army at Montoro.

4 comments:

  1. Thistlebarrow,

    An interesting result that felt realistic. The Spanish seem to be performing better than I would have expected although they do seem to be suffering rather high casualty rates ... and the retreat makes sense. Hopefully they will be able to hold the French in their new position.

    All the best,

    Bob

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Bob

      Thanks for your comments

      I am trying to get a historical "Spanish feel" for campaigns in southern Spain. In the last phase I concentrated on lines of supply and guerrilla activity, which I thought worked well. But it does not contribute to the table top games, which is the purpose of the whole campaign. This time I have increased the ratio of infantry and artillery in favour of the Spanish, though reducing the effectiveness of the artillery. This results in the French having to avoid too many casualties too early in the campaign. On the other hand they have to t ake two of the three objectives within 12 moves. So far they have failed to take the objectives, but inflicted so many casualties that it would be reasonable to make the Spanish retreat the next day. This is not entirely satisfactory, and I will be monitoring the future games to see if there is any way I can adjust the balance.

      Whilst most wargamers change period or scale when their interest wanes, I have to find a different way to revive interest. For me the 1813 campaign is the "only game in town" and I have invested too much time to perfecting the whole project to put it aside.

      regards
      Paul

      Delete
  2. Quite a realistic result. Karl von Clausewitz himself remarked that the cost of a battle victory might be so heavy as to compel a retreat....
    As usual, a fine looking battlefield!
    Cheers,
    Ion

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Ion

      Thanks for your comment

      I am pleased that you find the result realistic. I get so involved in the mechanics of the game, that I often lose the overall view. This is only the first battle of a campaign phase under serious adjustment, and to be a success the overall phase and the result will have to be an improvement on the previous model.

      But I am pleased with the results so far, and encouraged by your comment.

      regards
      Paul

      Delete

I have set the settings for comments to come to me before posting so that I will not miss any